Speed in 18th century (merchant, cutter, East Indiaman, naval brig)
- February 21, 2021 at 6:47 pm #21268christophe bParticipant
I’m a newbie here and I’m not a native English speaker. I was wondering if someone could help me with some questions about sailing speeds in the 18th century.
As far as I have learned, a ship-of-the-line could make about 12 knots, a frigate 14 knots at most (top speed). Averages would be between 5 and 8 knots approx. I also understand that for-and-aft rigged ship could sail faster while beating (close-hauled) than square-rigged ships.
It’s rather difficult to find inconsistent data about maximum speeds for sailing vessels like merchant ships (like an East Indiaman) or a cutter or a naval brig. Some sources give numbers like 8 knots. Could 8 knots be a top speed for a merchant ship, or is it an average speed for such vessels? Is a cutter as fast as a frigate or a schooner?
I’m not looking for average speeds. Data about average speeds (travelling the ocean) is not that hard to find.
ChristopheFebruary 27, 2021 at 5:05 pm #21297Frank ScottParticipant
This is a very complex subject.
How a vessel was loaded and trimmed made a lot of difference, this applied not just to merchant ships, but also to warships, whose performance could be improved immensely by loading to ensure best fore & aft trim.
Then you have to factor in captain & crew, because a theoretically inferior vessel with a superior crew invariable won in chase situations. In a square rigger or large schooner the range of movement of the centre of effort is substantial, which makes it all too easy to get the rig out of balance. The most obvious sign of this is excessive weather helm, which makes it more difficult to steer, and significantly slows down the ship. In general sail should be taken in from aft, keeping the angle of heel relatively low, all while taking careful note of the helm carried. Reducing sail in order to go faster may seem counter-intuitive, but being over-canvassed & thus sailing with massive angles of heel only increases drag and leeway.
It is not so much top speed or average speed that counts as speed differential. Then there is the issue of how well a vessel points when going to windward (how close to the wind it could sail). Here the Royal Navy benefited from having top quality canvas, closely woven and made from long fibre flax.
Note that coppering only comes in at the end of the eighteenth century, and that ensured that speeds within the fleet became more consistent, making it easier to keep together; and overall fleet speed increased, because even those ships longest out of dock were much less foul and thus quicker than in the pre-coppering era.
The ‘super-frigates’ that came in with the US Navy were heavily armed and very strongly built, but some of them were poor sailers compared to the smaller British frigates designed at the beginning of the Revolutionary & Napoleonic wars. For example, in the war of 1812 Samuel Leech observed that even in a patched-up condition the smaller Macedonian was a far better sailer than the United States, whose crew had nicknamed her ‘the Old Wagon’.March 2, 2021 at 7:49 pm #21321christophe bParticipant
Thanks Frank for your answer.
Is it als true that sailing close-hauled (or beating) is relatively more easy to make speed in light wind than in a strong wind?March 3, 2021 at 4:59 pm #21336Frank ScottParticipant
Speed under sail depends on combination of angle off the wind, wind velocity & sea state. As wind increases so does boat speed, until the wind is so strong that you need to reduce sail. Then there is the sea state factor, and the best scenario under any point of sailing is to be close inshore with an offshore wind, so the sea is much smoother than it would be in open water. Best point of sailing is with wind on the quarter, and when close-hauled ‘pinching up’ too close to the wind both reduces boat speed and increases leeway. Worst scenario is close-hauled in heavy weather with wind against tide situation.
The difference in performance between having a virtuoso on the helm compared to an average person is remarkable.
Nothing is easy in sailing.
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.